,
# especially if it merges an updated upstream into a topic branch.
#
# Lines starting with '#' will be ignored, and an empty message aborts
# the commit.
read_rsa_public_key() was bailing out early if the given node already has an Ed25519 key, and
returned true even though c->rsa was NULL. The early bailout code isn't necessary anymore, so just
remove it.
This deals with the case where one node knows the Ed25519 key of another node, but not the other
way around. This was blocked by an overly paranoid check in id_h(). The upgrade_h() function already
handled this case, and the node that already knows the other's Ed25519 key checks that it has not
been changed, otherwise the connection will be aborted.
Unfortunately, glibc assumes that /etc/resolv.conf is a static file that
never changes. Even on servers, /etc/resolv.conf might be a dynamically
generated file, and we never know when it changes. So just call
res_init() every time, so glibc uses up-to-date nameserver information.
Conflicts:
src/have.h
src/net.c
src/net_setup.c
Average RTT can be used to update edge weight and propagate it to the network.
tinc dump edges has been also extended to give the current RTT.
New edge weight will change only if the config has EdgeUpdateInterval set to other value than 0.
- Ignore local configuration for editors
- Extended manpage with informations about EdgeUpdateInterval
- Added clone_edge and fixed potential segfault when b->from not defined
- Compute avg_rtt based on the time values we got back in PONG
- Add avg_rtt on dump edge
- Send current time on PING and return it on PONG
- Changed last_ping_time to struct timeval
- Extended edge_t with avg_rtt
Testing has revealed that the newer series of Windows TAP drivers (i.e.
9.0.0.21 and later, also known as NDIS6, tap-windows6) suffer from
serious performance issues in the write path. Write operations seems to
take a very long time to complete, resulting in massive packet loss even
for throughputs as low as 10 Mbit/s.
I've made some attempts to alleviate the problem using parellelism. By
using custom code that allows up to 256 write operations at the same
time the results are much better, but it's still about 2 times worse
than the traditional 9.0.0.9 driver.
We need to investigate more and file a bug against tap-windows6, but in
the mean time, let's inform the user that he might not want to use the
latest drivers.
This is generally useful. We've seen issues that are specific to some
version of these drivers (especially the newer 9.0.0.21 version), so
it's relevant to log it, especially since that means it will be
copy-pasted by people posting their logs asking for help.
As a rule, it seems reasonable to make sure that tinc operates correctly
on at least 1G links, since these are pretty common. However, I have
observed replay window issues when operating at speeds of 600 Mbit/s and
above, especially when the receiving end is a Windows system (not sure
why). This commit increases the default so that this won't occur on
fresh setups.
It may not be obvious, but due to the way tinc operates (single-threaded
control loop with no intermediate packet buffer), UDP send and receive
buffers can have a massive impact on performance. It is therefore of
paramount importance that the buffers be large enough to prevent packet
drops that could occur while tinc is processing a packet.
Leaving that value to the OS default could be reasonable if we weren't
relying on it so much. Instead, this makes performance somewhat
unpredictable.
In practice, the worst case scenario occurs on Windows, where Microsoft
had the brillant idea of making the buffers 8K in size by default, no
matter what the link speed is. Considering that 8K flies past in a
matter of microseconds on >1G links, this is extremely inappropriate. On
these systems, changing the buffer size to 1M results in *obscene*
raw throughput improvements; I have observed a 10X jump from 40 Mbit/s
to 400 Mbit/s on my system.
In this commit, we stop trusting the OS to get this right and we use a
fixed 1M value instead, which should be enough for <=1G links.
Write operations to the Windows device do not necessarily complete
immediately; in fact, with the latest TAP-Win32 drivers, this never
seems to be the case.
write_packet() does not handle that case correctly, because the
OVERLAPPED structure and the packet data go out of scope before the
write operation completes, resulting in race conditions.
This commit fixes the issue by making sure these data structures are
kept in global scope, and by dropping any packets that may arrive while
the previous write operation is still pending.
On Windows, when disabling the device, tinc uses the CancelIo() to
cancel the pending read operation, and then proceeds to delete the event
handle immediately.
This assumes that CancelIo() blocks until the pending read request is
completely torn down and no references to it remain. While MSDN is not
completely clear on that subject, it does suggest that this is not the
case:
http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/desktop/aa363791.aspx
If the function succeeds [...] the cancel operation for all pending
I/O operations issued by the calling thread for the specified file
handle was successfully requested.
This implies that cancellation was merely "requested", and that there
are no guarantees as to the state of the operation when CancelIo()
returns. Therefore, care must be taken not to close event handles
prematurely.
While I'm no aware of this potential race condition causing any problems
in practice, I don't want to take any chances.
Modern versions of GCC handle structure packing differently when
compiling for Windows, as reported in the following GCC bug report:
http://gcc.gnu.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=52991
In practice, this affects tinc because it uses packed structs as a
convenient way to populate packet headers. "struct ip" is especially
affected - on Linux, sizeof(struct ip) returns 20 as expected, while on
Windows, it returns 24 because of the broken alignment.
This in turn completely breaks code that has to populate an IP header.
Specifically, this breaks route_ipv4_unreachable() which is responsible,
among other things, for the generation of ICMP Fragmentation Needed
messages. On Windows, these messages are corrupted beyond hope because
of this alignment issue. For TCP connections that are established
before tinc obtains a fix on the MTU (and thus are not MSS clamped),
this can result in massive disruption.
This commit fixes the issue by forcing GCC to use standard alignment
for all packed structures in the tinc codebase instead of the MSVC
alignment.
HAVE_DECL_RES_INIT is generated using AC_CHECK_DECLS. tinc checks this
symbol using #ifdef, which is wrong because (according to autoconf docs)
the symbol is always defined, it's just set to zero if the check failed.
This broke the Windows build starting from
0b310bf406, because it introduced this
conditional in code that's not excluded from the Windows build.
Ironically, commit 0f8e2cc78c introduced
a regression on its own, since it accidently removed a return statement
that prevented try_tx_sptps() from sending UDP/MTU probes to nodes that
are past static relays.
This makes sure MTU_INFO messages are only sent at the maximum rate of
5 per second (by default). As usual with these "probe" mechanisms, the
rate of these messages cannot be higher than the rate of data packets
themselves, since they are sent from the RX path.
This makes sure UDP_INFO messages are only sent at the maximum rate of
5 per second (by default). As usual with these "probe" mechanisms, the
rate of these messages cannot be higher than the rate of data packets
themselves, since they are sent from the RX path.
In this commit, nodes use MTU_INFO messages to provide MTU information.
The issue this code is meant to address is the non-trivial problem of
finding the proper MTU when UDP SPTPS relays are involved. Currently,
tinc has no idea what the MTU looks like beyond the first relay, and
will arbitrarily use the first relay's MTU as the limit. This will fail
miserably if the MTU decreases after the first relay, forcing relays to
fall back to TCP. More generally, one should keep in mind that relay
paths can be arbitrarily complex, resulting in packets taking "epic
journeys" through the graph, switching back and forth between UDP (with
variable MTUs) and TCP multiple times along the path.
A solution that was considered consists in sending standard MTU probes
through the relays. This is inefficient (if there are 3 nodes on one
side of relay and 3 nodes on the other side, we end up with 3*3=9 MTU
discoveries taking place at the same time, while technically only
3+3=6 are needed) and would involve eyebrow-raising behaviors such as
probes being sent over TCP.
This commit implements an alternative solution, which consists in
the packet receiver sending MTU_INFO messages to the packet sender.
The message contains an MTU value which is set to maximum when the
message is originally sent. The message gets altered as it travels
through the metagraph, such that when the message arrives to the
destination, the MTU value contained in the message can be used to
send packets while making sure no relays will be forced to fall back to
TCP to deliver them.
The operating principles behind such a protocol message are similar to
how the UDP_INFO message works, but there is a key difference that
prevents us from simply reusing the same message: the UDP_INFO message
only cares about relay-to-relay links (i.e. it is sent between static
relays and the information it contains only makes sense between two
adjacent static relays), while the MTU_INFO cares about the end-to-end
MTU, including the entire relay path. Therefore, UDP_INFO messages stop
when they encounter static relays, while MTU_INFO messages don't stop
until they get to the original packet sender.
Note that, technically, the MTU that is obtained through this mechanism
can be slightly pessimistic, because it can be lowered by an
intermediate node that is not being used as a relay. Since nodes have no
way of knowing whether they'll be used as dynamic relays or not (and
have no say in the matter), this is not a trivial problem. That said,
this is highly unlikely to result in noticeable issues in realistic
scenarios.
In this commit, nodes use UDP_INFO messages to provide UDP address
information. The basic principle is that the node that receives packets
sends UDP_INFO messages to the node that's sending the packets. The
message originally contains no address information, and is (hopefully)
updated with relevant address information as it gets relayed through the
metagraph - specifically, each intermediate node will update the message
with its best guess as to what the address is while forwarding it.
When a node receives an UDP_INFO message, and it doesn't have a
confirmed UDP tunnel with the originator node, it will update its
records with the new address for that node, so that it always has the
best possible guess as to how to reach that node. This applies to the
destination node of course, but also to any intermediate nodes, because
there's no reason they should pass on the free intel, and because it
results in nice behavior in the presence of relay chains (multiple nodes
in a path all trying to reach the same destination).
If, on the other hand, the node does have a confirmed UDP tunnel, it
will ignore the address information contained in the message.
In all cases, if the node that receives the message is not the
destination node specified in the message, it will forward the message
but not before overriding the address information with the one from its
own records. If the node has a confirmed UDP tunnel, that means the
message is updated with the address of the confirmed tunnel; if not,
the message simply reflects the records of the intermediate node, which
just happen to be the contents of the UDP_INFO message it just got, so
it's simply forwarded with no modification.
This is similar to the way ANS_KEY messages are currently
overloaded to provide UDP address information, with two differences:
- UDP_INFO messages are sent way more often than ANS_KEY messages,
thereby keeping the address information fresh. Previously, if the UDP
situation were to change after the ANS_KEY message was sent, the
sender would virtually never get the updated information.
- Once a node puts address information in an ANS_KEY message, it is
never changed again as the message travels through the metagraph; in
contrast, UDP_INFO messages behave the opposite way, as they get
rewritten every time they travel through a node with a confirmed UDP
tunnel. The latter behavior seems more appropriate because UDP tunnel
information becomes more relevant as it moves closer to the
destination node. The ANS_KEY behavior is not satisfactory in some
cases such as multi-layered graphs where the first hop is located
before a NAT.
Ultimately, the rationale behind this whole process is to improve UDP
hole punching capabilities when port translation is in effect, and more
generally, to make tinc more reliable in (very) hostile network
conditions (such as multi-layered NAT).
This commit adds a new command line option for tincd which allows to
use tincd in non-detached mode with log messages still going to
syslog. The motivation for this change is to ease use of tincd
in Docker containers.
If receive_handshake() or the receive_record() user callback returns an
error, sptps_receive_data_datagram() crashes the entire process. This is
heavy-handed, makes tinc very brittle to certain failures (i.e.
unexpected packets), and is inconsistent with the rest of SPTPS code.
Refactoring commit 81578484dc seems to
have introduced a regression as it moved discovery code away from
send_sptps_data_priv() and within send_packet(). The issue is,
send_packet() is not called when the node is simply relaying an UDP
SPTPS packet: indeed, send_sptps_data_priv() is called directly from
handle_incoming_vpn_data() in that case.
As a result, try_tx_sptps() is not called in the relaying case, which in
practice means that a relay doesn't initiate UDP/MTU discovery with the
next relay (unless some other activity compels it to do so). This can
result in packets getting sent over TCP instead of UDP from the relay.
Refactoring commit 0e65326047 broke UDP
SPTPS relaying by accidently removing try_tx_sptps() logic related to
establishing connectivity to so-called "dynamic" relays (i.e. relays
that are not specified by IndirectData configuration statements, but
are used on-the-fly to circumvent loss of direct UDP connectivity).
Specifically, the TX path was not trying to establish a tunnel to
dynamic relays (nexthop) anymore. This meant that MTU was not being
discovered with dynamic relays, which basically meant that all packets
being sent to dynamic relays went over TCP, thereby defeating the whole
purpose of SPTPS UDP relaying.
Note that this bug could easily go unnoticed if a tunnel was established
with the dynamic tunnel for some other reason (i.e. exchanging actual
data packets with the relay node).
Unfortunately, glibc assumes that /etc/resolv.conf is a static file that
never changes. Even on servers, /etc/resolv.conf might be a dynamically
generated file, and we never know when it changes. So just call
res_init() every time, so glibc uses up-to-date nameserver information.
